Gout is a painful disease of the joints, often associated with high-achieving intellectuals, and high fat diets, Benjamin Franklin, Isaac Newton, Charles Darwin, Henry the VIII, and Imanuel Kant had gout, to mention a few. Franklin wrote a dialogue with Madam Gout, at midnight, October 22, 1780, very funny. And six months ago it struck me too – less funny. I developed the classic symptoms: swelling, redness, and pain in my big, left toe.
I followed the classic cure: I drank lots of water, took aspirin (a mistake, apparently) and wrapped my toe using hockey tape. It helped slightly. A neighbor assured me it was gout, suggesting ibuprofen and a change of diet: Water, avoid meat, sugar, and alcohol. For a week, I did this and kept my toe wrapped, but it didn’t get better. So, I went to a foot specialist who removed the bandage, and pronounced it as gout, a disease caused by uric acid crystals in the joints. He took x-rays that showed nothing, prescribed a slightly different diet and a week of colchicine pills. He also suggested cortisone shots mixed with Novocain, I said no to the shots, but took the colchicine and followed the new diet for two weeks. But they did no good.

Then, one day, I wandered into a New Balance store. The lady asked if I wanted my foot measured, something that I’d not done in 35 years. I said “yes,” and discovered that my feet had expanded about a size and a half, from 9 wide to somewhere between 10 1/2 and 11. I bought comfortable jogging shoes in size 10 1/2, and found that the pain started going away almost immediately. Two months later, the pain is still gone, except for a few days after I tried wearing an old pair as an experiment. I’ve come to think that many, or most gout cases are not real gout at all, but inflammation from too-tight shoes. And even if you’ve got real gout, it couldn’t hurt to try bigger shoes, or get your feet remeasured.
Take a look at gout-related paintings from the 18th century, like in the one above. Generally, they show fat, old men with one foot wrapped, and the other in a small, tight shoe. It seems possible that, even back then, much of the gout was the result of too-tight shoes, or of over-eating without getting a bigger shoe to compensate.
Robert Buxbaum, November 10, 2026.

























