In 1940, Issac Asimov, perhaps the greatest of science fiction author, published the first of many robot stories where the plot does not go on mad and harm its makers as in “Frankenstein”, terminator, The robots in Asimov’s stories were mostly humanoid- AI, and always tried to be helpful to man within the limits of their intelligence and robotic free will.
A central part of these stories, written over 40+ years, was that any AI robot would be constrained by three, hard-wired rules (laws), the first of which prevented direct malevolence: “A robot may not harm a human or allow a human to come to harm through inaction.” Find the rest at right. Asimov believed that, without rules like this, no human would ever trust a AI-enabled machine of any sort, especially a humanoid.
Despite the hard-wired commitment of robots to not harm people, society didn’t trust them, and some humans hated them. The stories involve interaction problems of a wide variety, some caused by people, and some problems were from the fundamental difficulties of navigating life within these rules. There was even the occasional murder, but out of confusion, not malice. My favorite stories included a robot psychologist, Susan Calvin, born in 1982, called in when robot behaviors showed a sort of schizophrenic break. Despite the tension caused by the laws, it became clear that the laws were very beneficial, and not unrealistically restrictive. But that was all fiction.
The reality of AI robots is now here, but without the laws. Susan Calvin would be 44, and we now have robots with fairly advance AI. Some are even humanoid, and the most common use is to drive suicide drone ships used to kill humans. They fight the war in Ukraine and in Iran, and I notice that we’ve put no restrictions on bad behavior. To the contrary, the major use for these robots is killing people and destroying things. A predicted result is movies like the current “Top Gun” where robots fight humans and humans (barely) win. That humans win is likely wishful thinking, it seems to me. I noticed that some modifications were put to the most recent versions of Chat, suggesting a modest effort to put Asimov’s three basic restrictions on AI. It seems to me this restriction is more important on robots. While folks may trust a crazy AI, Asimov pointed out that no society will trust a machine that can get up and kill the owner as a result of malice or some simple mistake
As I write there’s talk of a committee being formed to regulate AI on a case by case basis, but no talk of regulating robots. In this, I’m worried that the committee will do more harm than good and will expand beyond simple safety to regulate AI thought. I suspect that the sort of people who manage to head this committee, will come to believe themselves worthy of regulating all thought. That is that they will become psychopaths if they aren’t already. These are last sort of people you’d want on the committee, but it’s what you’re likely to get. Some simple laws, thought seem worthwhile. The above 3 are a good place to start.
Robert Buxbaum November 20, 2026














